Ethnoveterinary medicinal plants and their utilization by indigenous and local communities of Dugda District, Central Rift Valley, Ethiopia

Background Ethnoveterinary medicinal plants have been used by the people of Dugda District in the primary health care system to treat various livestock ailments for generations, particularly, in underserved rural areas. However, these ethnoveterinary practices and medicinal plants are dwindling without proper documentation, due to undergoing socio-cultural and environmental changes. Hence, this study aimed at inventory and analysis of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants and the associated indigenous and local knowledge used in the treatment of livestock health problems in Dugda District. Methods Data were collected from 378 local inhabitants through semi-structured interviews, 18 focus group discussions with 6 to 8 participants in each couple with participant field observations. Informant consensus factor (ICF), fidelity-level (FL) and relative importance value (RI) were used to evaluate the agreement of informants on ethnoveterinary practices, healing potential of medicinal plants and the most multipurpose species. Using standard taxonomic procedures, voucher specimens were collected, identified and deposited at the National Herbarium of Addis Ababa University. Results In total, 64 medicinal plants of ethnoveterinary uses, belonging to 33 families were reported to treat 37 livestock health problems. Anthrax, inappetence and diarrhoea were said to be the most prevalent veterinary health problems treated by traditional medicinal plants. Family Fabaceae was the most widely reported (7 spp.), followed by Apocynaceae, Cucurbitaceae and Solanaceae (5 spp. each). Herbs were the dominant life forms (21spp.), followed by shrubs (20 spp.). The most commonly sought plant parts were leaves (55.25%), followed by roots (23.44%). The principal method of preparation was pounding remedial parts (46.85%) and mixing with cold water. The main route of administration was via oral application (72.67%), drenching diseased livestock. Withania somnifera and Kedrostis foetidissima were the most cited medicinal plants with 53 and 43 use reports (URs), respectively. ICF showed that respiratory diseases scored the highest value (0.94), while most of the reported medicinal plants were gastrointestinal agents. RI value analysis revealed that Croton macrostachyus had highest diversity of uses, followed by K. foetidissima and W. somnifera. Ethnoveterinary uses of some medicinal plants such as Phytolacca dodecandra, Calpurnia aurea, Cyphostemma cyphopetalum and Verbascum sinaiticum as prophylaxis against rabies were a new input for ethnoveterinary database. Conclusion The study revealed that the people of the Dugda District are endowed with rich ethnoveterinary knowledge and medicinal plants. However, ethnoveterinary knowledge associated with medicinal plant species significantly differ (P < 0.05) between general and key informants, young and matured age groups and informants’ educational level. This infers the impact of mode of ethnoveterinary knowledge transfer, literacy, modern education and globalization on ethnoveterinary uses of medicinal plant species. And also most of the medicinal plants are found in wild habitats with nearly no conservation attention. Therefore, it is imperative to implement participatory conservation actions for medicinal plants in collaboration with traditional institutions (Gada system). The disparity of ethnoveterinary knowledge could be also minimized through awareness creation among local communities about the knowledge and its revitalization. Furthermore, medicinal plants, which are widely utilized and multipurpose, should be screened for their phytochemicals, pharmacological and toxicological activities to confirm ethnoveterinary uses and for future development of veterinary pharmaceuticals.


Introduction
Ethnoveterinary medicine is a complex system of beliefs, knowledge, skills and practices concerning animal husbandry as well as general animal care [1].Although it mainly focuses on the use of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants to treat animal diseases, the practices of ethnoveterinary medicine also include the use of diagnostic procedures, animal husbandry practices and surgical methods [2].Recently, this system has gained attention for its potential usefulness in contributing to livestock wellbeing, particularly at the level of primary animal healthcare [3].In many rural areas of the world, particularly in remote and marginal areas, traditional herbal medicines are crucial to treating domestic animals.This is due to several reasons, including cost-effectiveness, accessibility, efficacy and safety; one remedy for various ailments; and viable alternatives to allopathic drugs [4,5].Martin et al. [6] noted that the role of ethnoveterinary medicine in livestock development is beyond dispute.
In traditional societies around the world, particularly in developing countries, a lot of people have a close relationship with livestock.Livestock is an important and integral part of many economies of these nations [7], which span from the social to the economic to the environmental [8].In Ethiopia, livestock is a vital and basic component of agricultural production.The country is among the leading countries in Africa in livestock population, with 65 million cattle, 40 million sheep, 51 million goats, 8 million camels and 49 million chickens [9].It contributes up to 40% of agricultural gross domestic product (GDP), nearly 20% of total GDP and 20% of national foreign exchange earnings [10].Livestock is a major source of animal proteins, food security, transport of goods, export products, manure for household energy and means of wealth accumulation.It also provides draught power and manure for crop cultivation, which improve soil fertility and aid productivity [11,12].
However, the livestock sector is constrained by many factors, such as rampant livestock diseases that affect livestock productivity, the marketability of their products and economic losses [13,14].Livestock diseases negatively affect the income and farming activities of the rural poor, which in turn has implications for the livelihood of the farmers [15,16].It remains one of the principal causes of poor livestock performance, leading to an ever-increasing gap between supply and demand for livestock products [17].The impact is highly manifested in cultures where livestock is equated with wealth [17].This is directly related to low accessibility to modern livestock health care, veterinarians and the supply of drugs, even if they are accessible but not affordable to the majority of farmers [18].As a result, medicinal plants are frequently used to treat different livestock diseases, particularly, in areas where modern veterinary services are absent, expensive, inaccessible and scanty [15,16,18].
In Ethiopia, Ethnoveterinary service is believed to have been in practice since time immemorial.The diverse ethnolinguistic communities in Ethiopia are very familiar with the therapeutic potential of medicinal plants as ethnoveterinary medicines.Traditional remedies are major sources of therapeutics for nearly 90% of the livestock population in Ethiopia, and of all forms of traditional medicines in the country, 95% are made of medicinal plants [19].Thus, traditional healers are potentially important first-line health care providers because they often primarily rely on plant remedies to treat livestock ailments with cheap payment or free of charge in the absence of modern veterinary services [20].This makes ethnoveterinary practices an integral part of primary health care, especially for marginalized and poor communities living in remote rural areas.Interestingly, practice varies from one place to another and dictated by the diverse culture and tradition of the people as well as the vegetation of a particular area [15].In Ethiopia, ethnoveterinary medicinal plants are used to treat commonly encountered livestock diseases such as anthrax, blackleg, diarrhoea, wounds, bloat, intestinal worms, external parasites and mastitis [14,21].Tilahun et al. [21] stated that the predominant medicinal plants in Ethiopian ethnoveterinary medications are Croton macrostachyus, Solanum incanum, Calpurnia aurea and Withania somnifera.
On the other hand, ethnoveterinary knowledge and medicinal plants are at risk of extinction due to ecological and technological changes, access to modern health facilities and anthropogenic and natural factors that threaten the existence of many plant species of veterinary importance [5,22].Its mode of transfer and documentation is mainly oral and apprenticeship specific, which leads to the risk of losing such important knowledge that cannot be regained [3,22].In addition, rapid socio-economic and outward rural migrations and the paucity of research on the ethnoveterinary uses of medicinal plants in treating livestock diseases further undermine its relevance [23].Hence, there is consequently a need to scientifically record, document, promote the use of ethnoveterinary medications and the conservation of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants [19].Such studies can aid in proposing effective and cheaper treatment alternatives to veterinary diseases, enhance ethnoveterinary medicinal plant conservation and provide information for experimentation studies in search of modern pharmaceuticals [2,5,24].These and other related issues have enhanced ethnoveterinary medicine inventories in recent years in Africa [25,26], and similarly, in Ethiopia [15,19,[27][28][29][30][31][32][33].
The study District is situated in the Central Rift Valley of Ethiopia, between the eastern escarpment and the western escarpment [34,35], with relatively high biodiversity, but is under great pressure due to agricultural economic corridors and highway constructions, among others.The District has a high livestock population of cattle, sheep, goats and donkeys under the traditional animal husbandry system.In addition to modern veterinary services, local communities use ethnoveterinary medicinal plants and associated traditional knowledge to sustain the health of their livestock.But these knowledge and medicinal plants are becoming fragile due to environmental change, overuse, acculturation, weakening of social structures and verbal modes of knowledge transfer, which lead to information loss and threaten medicinal plants.Consequently, there is a need to document the available indigenous ethnoveterinary knowledge and practices with their respective medicinal plants.In fact, several ethnoveterinary studies have reported veterinary uses of Ethiopian medicinal plants, but compared to the rich cultural and plant diversity in the country, it is still not at the expected level, and to the best of our knowledge, no ethnobotanical research has yet been done on ethnoveterinary practices and medicinal plants in Dugda District.Therefore, the current research aimed (1) to document ethnoveterinary uses of medicinal plants to fill the gap and identify the most potential ethnoveterinary medicinal plants, (2) to quantify consent on ethnoveterinary practices, healing potential and multipurpose ethnoveterinary medicinal plants using relevant ethnobotanical indices and (3) to find new ethnoveterinary medicinal plants used in Dugda District, which could be important source for the discovery of new veterinary pharmaceuticals.

Description of the study area
The research was conducted in Dugda District located within the Central Rift Valley, Oromia National Regional State, Ethiopia.The study area was selected based on presence of rich indigenous knowledge (Gada system), other cultural factors and pressure on remnant woodlands and bushlands patches due to demand for farmlands, irrigation and wood products for different purposes such as charcoal making and collection of fuelwood and construction materials.The study area topographically lies within agro-climate zone called subtropical (Weina Dega/Badda-daree) and semi-arid.The landscape is characterized by flat topped plain, valley, mountains and grouped under drought prone highland.The major soil types are sandy loam and clay loam, which have good drainage capacity suitable for irrigation and rain fed crop production.The total area covered by the District is 95,945 ha and situated at 8°01′ N-8°10′ N latitude 38°31′ E-38 °57′ E longitude and with an altitude 1600-2020 m above sea level (Fig. 1).The average annual rainfall varies from 700 to 800 mm and the temperature ranges from 22° to 28 °C; such rainfall and temperature patterns are relatively, suitable for crop production, animal husbandry and human habitation.Ethnographically, the indigenous people inhabiting the study area belong to the Oromo known as Jille Oromo, the largest ethnic group in Ethiopia, and speak Afaan Oromo, and people with different ethnic backgrounds have also settled there.Mostly the local people are farmers, as a result their economy is based on mixed crop-livestock farming system and fishing.The main agricultural activities are rain fed grain/cereal crops production, irrigation for vegetables and fruit production and livestock farming.The indigenous communities have long tradition of livestock husbandry, particularly, cattle have special place, as key for local economy, source of their livelihood and cultural values.The District is rich in livestock population, with 323,129 cattle, 98,239 sheep, 87,764 goats, 24,194 donkeys, 6,390 horses and 2,645 mules and as well as 251,974chicken (Dugda District Agricultural Office, unpublished data of 2021).The economically important livestock diseases in the District were anthrax, blackleg, bacterial diseases, lumpy skin disease (LSD), Newcastle disease and African horse sickness (AHS) (Dugda District Agricultural Office, unpublished data of 2021).Regarding veterinary services in the District, there are 14 Type D veterinary clinics to service 38 rural kebeles and only one Type B clinic at the District centre Meki town.A total of 32 veterinarians are delivering veterinary services in the District, which include Doctor of Veterinary Medicine (5), Bachelor in Veterinary Science (10), Animal Health Assistances (16) and Veterinary Laboratory Technician (1) (Dugda District Agricultural Office, unpublished data of 2021).The vegetation of the area is described as Acacia-Commiphora woodland and bushland land (ACB) under subdivision Acacia wooded grassland of the Rift Valley (ACB/RV), mostly dominated by Acacia spp.including Vachellia tortilis, Senegalia senegal, Vachellia seyal and Balanites aegyptiaca [34][35][36].This Acacia dominated woodland is a highly fragile ecosystem adapted to semi-arid conditions with erratic rainfall, growing on complex and vulnerable hydrological system.The District also has wetland plants such as Setaria geminata, Typha domingensis, Cyperus papyrus, Nymphaea nouchali and Aeschynomene elaphroxylon [36].Vegetation of the study area, particularly woodlands and wetlands, are the mainstay of local communities, being vital sources of fuelwood, construction materials, fodder, shade, medicinal plants, wild food plants, farm implements and honey flora.For example, V. tortilis for charcoal and firewood; T. domingensis for thatching, A. elaphroxylon for firewood, roofing and utensils; and S. senegal and Faidgerbia albida are used for fencing.And some big trees and shrubs like Ficus sycomorus, Solanum incanum, Podocarpus falcatus, Premna schimperi, Ficus vasta and V. tortilis are also socio-culturally important as symbol, sacred and spiritual connections.

Gada system, livestock and plant conservation
Jille Oromos had traditional governance called Gada system, which deals with all-encompassing social, economic, cultural and political activities.Just like other Oromos in different parts of Ethiopia, Jille Oromos have five Gada party in their Gada system including Birmaji, Melba, Mudana, Halchisa and Robale, where all have their own leader called Abba Gada, transfer power peacefully and each lead for eight years.But before transfer of power each Gada parts have to learn laws and fetch those laws by moving to Oda Nabe (near Bishoftu city) with their livestock mainly cattle (Caffe Godansa).These laws include law of God (Sera Waqa), laws of land (Sera Lafa), laws of father and mother (Sera Abba fi Hadha) and laws related to other socio-cultural practices.Abba Gada has advisors called Ayyantu (Raga), in which they consult these reputable persons in their Gada period for each and every activities.Ayyantu is respected person in the society that had God given ability to forecast good fortune and challenges that would happen a year or in eight years of each Gada period.These situation could be related to an individual or the whole society, such as rainy seasons of the year, livestock diseases, war/conflict, peace, drought and famine.In doing this, they have established a kind of trend that would happen in each Gada period, for example, in Gada Birmaji there would be high frequency of livestock diseases, Gada Melba known by conflict and truth, Gada Mudana by plenty of rain and prosperity, Gada Halchisa good for livestock productivity and Gada Robale known by drought and famine.Thus, Gada system had important role in livestock production and welfare, based on each circumstances in each Gada period these would make livestock keepers be prepared beforehand, to locate alternative grazing lands and water resources for their livestock.Furthermore, Gada system had a concept of plant conservation, by prohibiting cutting of respected plants and protection of places of Gada practices (Arda Jila/ Malka).These plant species include Ficus sycomorus (Oda), F. thonningii, Podocarpus falcatus, Premna schimperi, Phoenix reclinata and Cordia Africana.The aforementioned plant species and others are also important in Gada practices as sources of material cultures, constructions, ritual grounds, praying and blessings.One typical example of sacred place in the study area is a place called Oda Tuta (group of F. sycomorus trees), where over 200 F. sycomorus stands found in one place and serve for various Gada events.However, nowadays such practices are weakening due to various factors and need attention and revitalization for plant biodiversity and associated indigenous knowledge conservations.

Participant selection and interviewing process
Ethnoveterinary survey was conducted during several field trips made between April 2020 and June 2021 in 18 kebeles of Dugda District.The reconnaissance survey was carried out prior to data collection and the researchers got overview on vegetation types, ethnoveterinary knowledge of medicinal plants, knowledgeable people, natural resource management and conservation practices.The study kebeles were selected with the help of Development Agents, local leaders, elders and observation during the reconnaissance survey, based on the vegetation cover and availability of knowledgeable people on ethnoveterinary medicinal plants (Fig. 1).The key informants were selected through purposive and snowball techniques [37].The representative general informants were selected through systematic random sampling techniques following the methods described by Martin [38].During selection of informants different socio-demographic characteristics of the informants were considered.A total of 378 informants (from 18 kebeles (subdistricts or smallest administrative units in Ethiopian Admin system), 21 informants each) were sampled, where general informants (288) were selected in volunteer and interviewed, during field trips made in the respective study kebeles.Nominations on knowledgeable persons on medicinal plants to participate as key informants was made by the help of elderly people, Development Agents and village leaders in the study kebeles.Following this, a total of 90 traditional healers (27 female and 63 male) were selected.These healers have high reputation with respect to their traditional knowledge on medicinal plants and long-term ethnoveterinary services.Regarding gender of informants' , male informants were 250, while 128 informants were female.The age of the informants' ranges between 20 and 87 years.They are distributed into two age groups, 131 informants (20-39) young group and 247 informants  matured group, where 40 years old is considered as turning into maturity in knowledge and leadership.The majority of the interviewed informants were illiterate (257, 67.99%), who did not attend school.And occupationally, most informants were farmers (313, 82.80%), who's daily livelihood mainly based on agricultural activities like crop production and livestock farming (Table 1).

Ethnobotanical data collection
Ethnoveterinary medicine data were collected using semi-structured interviews, focus group discussions, participant field observations and with very close interaction with informants.The semi-structured interview in the field survey with informants were conducted in local language called "Afaan Oromo" following method described in Martin [38].The appropriate ethical permission to conduct the research was obtained through formal letter by Addis Ababa University (AAU) to Dugda District authority and local community leaders (Kebeles).Before interview process, government bodies at district and kebele levels, and all informants were briefed about the research objectives and its academic purposes.Indeed, prior informed consent was obtained verbally from each informant before the commencement of interviews, then semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions were conducted.The semi-structured interview contained questions on socio-economic and demographic characteristics regarding name, age, sex, level of education, occupation, religion and ethnicity of informants.Information regarding local names of medicinal plants, ailments treated, habitats of the species, degree of management (wild/cultivated), part/parts used, conditions of plant part used (fresh/dried), other ingredients or additives, methods of remedy preparations, routes of remedy administration, noticeable adverse effects of remedies, use of antidotes for adverse effects, taboos/beliefs related to collection and use of plant, source of knowledge, methods of indigenous knowledge transfer, other use of medicinal plants, existing threats and traditional conservation practices (if any) were collected following ethnobotanical methods described in [16,19,39].Further, focus group discussions (6-8 informants) in each study kebeles (subdistrict) were conducted to validate, clarify and harmonize the results obtained through semistructured interviews [40].Besides, guided field observations were performed with key informants which create an opportunity for more discussion on different issues, and useful in describing and practical identification of medicinal plants, identifying different vegetation types and land-use impacts by indicating problems or possible solutions following the method described by Cunningham [41].Finally, informants' description of livestock ailment types was translated with the consultation of veterinarians working in the study area and then translated into veterinary terms.
Voucher specimens of the medicinal plant cited for their ethnoveterinary services were collected and identified at least in their local names with the help of key informants during guided field observations, following standard botanical collection procedures.Plant voucher specimens were collected from natural vegetation, woodlands, grasslands, farmlands and home-gardens during the field walks with the help of informants and local field assistants.Voucher specimen identification was done in the field and later at the National Herbarium (ETH) of Addis Ababa University (AAU) using taxonomic keys provided in the relevant volumes of Flora of Ethiopia and Eritrea [42][43][44][45][46][47][48].The specimen identification was confirmed by a plant taxonomic expert at AAU.The identified voucher specimens were numbered, labelled and deposited in the ETH.Plant scientific names were updated according to the World Flora Online (WFO, http:// www.world flora online.org) and databases such as PubMed, Google Scholar, ScienceDirect and Springer-Link were used for literature collection and compiled in Zotero, then compared with the present study.

Quantitative ethnobotanical data analysis
Ethnoveterinary data were arranged and organized by using Microsoft Excel spreadsheet software (Microsoft Excel, 2013).Quantitatively analysed using descriptive statistic methods like percentile and frequency distribution were used to summarize medicinal plant data based on use reports.The raw data of ethnoveterinary medicinal species were summarized and reported in table form with their scientific name, family name, local name, growth form, ailment treated, plant parts used, ailments, livestock types treated, conditions of plant part used, method of preparation and application, route of administration and collection number.The statistical test of significance was performed using independent sample t test on the number of medicinal plants cited by different groups: gender (male and female), age (young and matured), informant type (key and general informants) and educational level (illiterate and literate).The analysis of quantitative ethnobotanical data was conducted using informant consensus factor (ICF), fidelity-level (FL) and relative importance (RI) formulas as described below.

Informant consensus factor (ICF)
The informant consensus factor (ICF) values was used to assess the homogeneity or degree of agreement of the informants' knowledge about medicinal plants, which help to determine the most important livestock ailment categories in the study area.It is calculated as follows: where n = number, and UR = use report (s), while t = plant (s) [39,49,50].

Fidelity level (FL)
Fidelity level (FL) of the medicinal plants conducted to compare and determine relative healing potential of medicinal plants based on ailment category.It was computed as follows: where Ip is the number of informants who independently cited ailment category and Iu the total number of informants who reported the plants for any given ailment category [51].

Relative importance (RI)
Relative importance (RI) of each cited medicinal plant was calculated using a method by Bennett and Prance [52].RI was calculated using: where NP is obtained as: number of specific ailments treated by a given species divided by the total number of specific ailments treated by the most multipurpose species.NCS is the number of ailment categories treated by a given species divided by the total number of ailment categories treated by the most multipurpose species.Species with RI value close to 2 are the ones with the highest diversity of medicinal application and close to 0 least diversity of medicinal application.

Results
Major livestock diseases in the study area  2.

Taxonomic diversity ethnoveterinary medicinal plants
In this study, a total of 64 ethnoveterinary plants belonging to 58 genera and 33 families were reported to treat different livestock ailments.Of the total, the majority of plant species (52) were native or indigenous to Ethiopia and a single plant species was recorded as endemic (Kalanchoe petitiana).In addition, among total ethnoveterinary medicinal plants, 11 (17.19%)plant species were introduced and five plant species (7.81%) were identified as invasive alien species (Tables 9 and 10).The analysis of botanical families of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants showed that 33 plant families were involved in ethnoveterinary practices of Dugda District.Of the total plant families, 65.62% of medicinal plants were contributed by eleven plant families, where as 34.38% come from the remaining families.Family Fabaceae was the best represented, with seven medicinal plant species, followed by Apocynaceae, Cucurbitaceae and Solanaceae, with five species each, Malvaceae and Vitaceae, with four species each (Fig. 2).The results from life forms of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants indicated that herbs were the most frequently utilized life forms in ethnoveterinary services of the study area, with 21 species (32.81%), and followed by shrubs 20 (31.25%).The other therapeutic life forms utilized in remedy preparation were climbers 13 (20.13%)and trees 10 (15.63%).

Plant parts used for remedy preparation
The analysis of plant parts used for ethnoveterinary remedy preparations revealed that leaves were the most frequently used plant parts, which come from 36 species (56.25%), followed by root (15 species, 23.44%), whole part (8, 12.50%) and fruits (6, 9.38%).In addition, other plant parts such as stem bark, latex, seeds, bulbs, stem, tuber and young shoot were also sought for remedy preparations in ethnoveterinary practices of the study District, with low percent of contribution (Fig. 3).
Regarding condition of plant parts during remedy preparations, the majority (92.19%) of remedies were prepared from freshly harvested plant parts and a few preparations from fresh/dry (10.94%) and dry (9.38%) plant parts.

Modes of remedy preparation and application
The local people and traditional healers of the Dugda District have reported several traditional methods used in preparation and application of ethnoveterinary remedies for treatment of various ailments in livestock.Among these modes of preparation and application, pounding and drenching (46.85%) was the most common mode of remedy preparation and application, followed by grinding and drenching (18.18%), and pounding, spraying, washing and pasting (7.69%) (Fig. 4).Pounding, best way of preparation in the area, where plant parts as mono-preparation or poly-herbal preparation are pounded using a wooden mortar and pestle, then soaked in cold water to get intended veterinary remedies.The majority of ethnoveterinary remedies (84.31%) were formulated from single plant species, but only 15.69% of the remedies were made from poly-herbal (multi-plants) formulations, i.e. ethnoveterinary remedies prepared from concoction of two or more medicinal plant species (Tables 9 and 10).
For instance, poly-herbal preparation from concoction of eight medicinal plants; roots from Cyphostemma cyphopetalum, Withania somnifera, Cucumis ficifolius, Foeniculum vulgare, and leaves from Dodonaea viscosa subsp.angustifolia, Gymnanthemum amygdalinum (Synonym: Vernonia amygdalina), Marsdenia schimperi, (Synonym: Dregea schimperi), and young shoots of Croton macrostachyus.These all medicinal plant parts were reported to be pounded together, mixed with cold water and salt, being effective remedy for cattle ailments, namely anthrax, blackleg, LSD and bovine ephemeral fever (BEF).In either ways, cold water was the most frequently used solvent to extract bioactive ingredients found in ethnoveterinary medicinal plants of the study area.After preparation, the traditional healers administer remedies to diseased livestock as drenches without sieving.In addition to plant materials and water, some other ingredients were also used in formulations of remedies, these include: salt, soot/charcoal, used petrol, kerosene, food, saliva, milk, blood, butter/ghee, whey and skimmed milk.
On top of all, the important process in ethnoveterinary medicine or ethnomedicine practice is locating sources of medicinal plants by practitioners.In the study area, local people and traditional healers travel in search of fresh ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in different habitats/places including woodlands, parklands, farmlands, farm margins, fence, homestead, wetlands, riverine, on host trees for mistletoes and bought from markets, as the need of ethnoveterinary medicines arise.The data on sources of medicinal plants showed that indigenous the people of the study area mostly utilize wild medicinal plant resources (53 species), while a few (11 species) medicinal plants were recorded as cultivated and semi-wild, six and five medicinal plant species, respectively.

Routes of ethnoveterinary remedy administration
Ethnoveterinary remedies for livestock in Dugda District were administered through different administration routes based on encountered ailments.The dominant administration route was oral (72.67%), followed by dermal (12%) and nasal (7%).The remaining routes of administration were less frequently used applications (Fig. 5).Oral application, the most frequently applied route of remedy administration, is practiced as drenching herbal remedy through mouth of the diseased livestock.
In connection with this, farmers and traditional healers determine the dosage of remedies, after visual inspections of the diseased animals, on the basis of age, sex, physical condition of the diseased animals, severity of the disease, types of animals and pregnancy status of animals.The veterinary remedies were measured by variety of instruments such as finger length, Can, glass, plastic jug, coffee cup, bottle, number of drops and number of plant heads.Although there is no standardized dose, a wide ranges of doses were applied for treatment of livestock diseases, starting from single drop via left nostril and ear of dogs and cats (prophylaxis against rabies) to two Can (approximately two litre) to treat diseases like anthrax, blackleg, BEF and LSD.Similarly, the administration frequency of remedies delivered to the diseased animals ranges from only once to until the animals recovered from the disease.
Ethnoveterinary medicines, prepared from aforementioned and other therapeutic plant species, are reported to be utilized for the treatment of various ailments of domestic animals.The majority of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants (56 species, 87.50%) were used to treat cattle, followed by goats and sheep (16, 25%), all livestock (12, 18.75%), equines (10, 15.63%), dogs and cats (5, 7.81%), but only single preparation (1, 1.56%) was reported for treatment of chicken disease.

Ethnoveterinary ailment category
A total of 37 ailments of the livestock were recorded in Dugda District.These ailments were further categorized into nine ailment categories, and then, informants' consensus factor (ICF) values were calculated for each categories.The output of ICF values ranges from 0.69 to 0.94.The ailment category with the highest ICF value was respiratory diseases (0.94).The other ailment categories were external parasitic diseases (0.91), gastrointestinal diseases (0.88), dermatological diseases (0.85), neurological diseases (0.83) and musculoskeletal diseases (0.81) (Table 4).Even though gastrointestinal diseases ranked at third place next to external parasitic diseases, the ailment category was reported to be treated by high number of medicinal plants with informants citations (34 species, 267 citation), followed by dermatological diseases (26,168), and general illness diseases (24,89).

Medicinal plants used to treat ethnoveterinary ailment category
Relative healing potential of main medicinal plants used to treat each ailment category was evaluated by calculating their fidelity level (FL).Accordingly, the FL values of the three most cited medicinal plants for the treatment of ethnoveterinary ailment category were presented in (Table 5).The results of FL values of medicinal plants showed that there was high degree of agreement (> 50% FL) on selection of medicinal plants used to treat gastrointestinal, dermatological, reproductive, respiratory and ophthalmologic diseases categories, while external parasitic and general illness categories showed low agreement (< 50% FL).For example, high fidelity-level values were obtained for Melia azedarach (92%), Kedrostis foetidissima (67.4%) and Croton macrostachyus (58.8%) to treat gastrointestinal disease category.

Relative importance of ethnoveterinary plants
The relative importance of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants was analysed to identify the most multipurpose (use diversity) medicinal plants based on the number of specific ailments and ailment categories treated by these plants.Accordingly, 27 (42.19%)medicinal plants were used to treat two or more specific ailment; likewise, about 25 (39.06%)medicinal plants were utilized to manage two and more ailment categories.The relative importance analysis (RI) revealed that Croton macrostachyus  had highest diversity of uses (2), followed by Kedrostis foetidissima, Withania somnifera, Phytolacca dodecandra and Senna occidentalis (Table 5).Interestingly, the majority of reported medicinal plants were used as gastrointestinal agents (53.13%), followed by dermatological agents (43.10%), general illness agents (40.63%), musculoskeletal agents (21.88%) and neurological agents (18.75%) (Table 6).

Distribution of ethnoveterinary medicinal plant knowledge
The statistical test of significance was performed using independent sample t test on the number of medicinal plants cited by informant groups in the study District.The result of independent sample t test revealed that there was significance difference (P < 0.05) between key and general informants on the number of medicinal plant species.Similarly, there was significance difference (P < 0.05) between the two age groups; young group  (20-39 years) and matured group (40-87 years) informants.Significance difference (P < 0.05) was also obtained between illiterate and literate informants on the number of medicinal plant species mentioned.However, there was no significance difference (P > 0.05) in the number of medicinal plants reported by male and female informants (Table 7).

Livestock ailments and diversity of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants
In Dugda District, similar to other part of Ethiopia, livestock is an important and integral wealth of indigenous people, where livestock provide cash income and foods, means of transportation, draught power, wealth accumulation (Kila lixu), socio-cultural values as gift upon marriage (Gabra/Biti and Tirma/Gega'o), in religious practices (Fala), Gada system (Butta qalu) and other cultural events.However, livestock populations, particularly cattle are frequently affected by livestock ailments including anthrax, inappetence, diarrhoea, rabies, blackleg and mange, which deteriorate health and productivity.These ailments are also among the top prevalent livestock ailment in the study District, which are also among the commonly encountered ailments throughout the country and commonly reported to be treated by herbal medications [14,21].Similar ethnoveterinary inventories conducted elsewhere in Ethiopia also showed the prevalence of anthrax, inappetence, diarrhoea, rabies, blackleg and mange, including researches by Yineger et al. [16] at Bale Mountains National Park, Giday and Teklehaymanot [18] in Afar people of Ada'ar District, Kidane et al. [15] in Maale and Ari ethnic communities, Lulekal et al. [19] for people of Ankober District, and Assefa and Bahiru [29] at Abergelle, Sekota and Lalibela  districts.Although the outbreak and prevalence of livestock diseases varies among the areas due to climatic differences, the comparison showed similar disease-causing factors, wide prevalence and serious economic impact of these diseases in the country, beside a nearly similar livestock's management system throughout the country.Most importantly, a good number of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants (64) are reported to be used in management of livestock ailments in Dugda District, pertinent to availability, cultural acceptability, affordability and efficacy to treat livestock [2].This is supported by the argument of Van der Merwe et al. [2] who stated that the indications for ethnoveterinary medicines in livestock are similar in different areas, but the ethnoveterinary medicinal plants used are usually different, based on locally available plant populations.In general, indigenous and local people of a given area developed an indigenous and local knowledge system that best fits to select and use diverse curative medicinal plants to treat frequently occurring livestock diseases [19] and less severe diseases and or injuries [53].
Interestingly, the use of herbal remedies to treat livestock ailments is still alive in the Dugda District.The result showed that in the District, farmers and traditional healers are rich in ethnoveterinary knowledge and utilize medicinal plants to treat livestock ailments.This may be related to the inhabitants' strong relationship with livestock, its location between Arsi and Gurage Highlands.It could be also attributed to familiarity of local people to ethnoveterinary remedies, which make them feel safe in using traditional remedies.In addition, movement with livestock in search of grazing land (Godansa) and Gada grade celebrations (Chaffe Godansa), where they fetch law governing everything including livestock, human being and natural resources.Such activities might have helped them to keep the traditional livestock healing culture and share among themselves and beyond.And the presence of medicinal plants (64) indicated the potential of the District as an ethnoveterinary resource pool, despite the high rate of degraded habitats that continued for so long, its semi-arid nature and drought prone.Similar ethnoveterinary studies elsewhere in Ethiopia also reported comparable number of medicinal plants, to mention a few, 43 medicinal plants [17]; 46 [15]; 49 [18]; 51 [19]; and 53 [29].Some of the studies documented higher number of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants than the current results, such as by Yineger et al. [16] (74 species), Yigezu et al. [33] (74) and Dinbiso et al. [54] (103), at Bale Mountains National Park, four districts of Jima Zone and Dawuro Zone of Ethiopia, respectively.Thus, the present and early ethnoveterinary inventories showed the importance of medicinal plants in management of different livestock ailments, particularly, in areas where modern veterinary services are absent, expensive, inaccessible and scanty [15].This could be also related to poverty, the availability of medicinal plants, better accessibility and low cost of herbal medications.However, ethnoveterinary practices are vary from place to place and that is related to the diverse culture and tradition of the people as well as the vegetation type of a particular area [15].
The analysis of botanical families of ethnoveterinary plants revealed that Fabaceae, Apocynaceae, Cucurbitaceae, Solanaceae, Malvaceae and Vitaceae families are the dominant families in ethnoveterinary medication systems of Dugda District.This finding is in line with other similar ethnoveterinary studies conducted elsewhere in Ethiopia [15,18,19,27,29,31,33], where these families were reported as important in their respective ethnoveterinary services.The greater number of species in these families could be attributed to their wide distribution and abundance in the Acacia wooded grassland of the Rift Valley (ACB/RV) vegetation, the study area in particular.The member species of these families have developed drought-resistant mechanisms to dwell in semi-arid dry land of Great Rift Valley of Ethiopia.Besides, Fabaceae, Cucurbitaceae, Solanaceae and Apocynaceae families are also among the top 25 families of vascular plants of Ethiopian flora area [55] and most frequently utilized plant families to treat livestock ailments in the country [21].Thus, the preference of members of these families could be related to availability in close vicinity, presence of bioactive ingredients in member of these families and longterm familiarity with these herbal materials [56].
In the study area, various types of medicinal plants' life forms are employed, among which herbs accounted the highest share, followed by shrubs.The dominance of herbaceous species could be related to their rapid grow during bimodal rainy seasons of the area, availability around homestead and ease of collection.As described in Giday and Teklehaymanot [18], shrubby species are also better adapted to arid conditions as compared to plants of other life forms, which made them abundant and available in such areas for farmers and pastoralists in need.Frequent use of herbs in ethnoveterinary medications were reported in ethnoveterinary studies investigated in different part of Ethiopia [15,16,32,54,57], similarly others recorded shrubs as important herbal medications [18,19,27,28].In contrast to present finding, tree species constituted the largest share in other ethnoveterinary studies [22,29,33].This similarity and variation in utilization of life forms of ethnoveterinary plants in different communities could be attributed to agro-ecological settings, indigenous knowledge exchange and independent development of indigenous knowledge in their respective communities.

Plant parts used for remedy preparation
The other important attributes of ethnoveterinary plants analysed were plant parts used for preparation of veterinary remedies.The study revealed that leaves are the most sought plant part for remedies preparation followed by roots.This collection of leaves as major ethnoveterinary treatments could be related to high phytochemical constituents, ease of collection and preparation of remedies, and readily availability in time of need.In agreement with current result, leaves have been reported as commonly utilized plant parts in ethnoveterinary medical systems of different ethnic groups of Ethiopia [15,18,22,28,31,33,54,58] and elsewhere in the world [25,[59][60][61][62][63].These findings differ from the results of Yineger et al. [16] who reported frequent use of roots in ethnoveterinary medical system of communities living around Bale Mountains National Park of Ethiopia.Interestingly, use of leaves as a single remedy or concoction with other parts in the study area is important for sustainable utilization of medicinal resources, because leaves are renewable resources of medicinal plants in contrary to the roots.Several studies [18,59] indicated that gathering leaves are recommendable, as its collection does not result the death of the entire plant.However, conservation issues have been raised by other studies [19,63], due to ethnobotanical collection of roots and whole parts, which may be destructive and unsustainable, as harvesting of roots may increase the risk of the medicinal plants extinction.
Ethnoveterinary remedy of Dugda District is largely prepared from freshly harvested plant parts.Preference of freshly made remedies could be attributed to attaining volatile essential oils and secondary metabolites, which are important to fight disease-causing agents in livestock with high efficacy and curative power, these bioactive ingredients will escape or be degraded upon drying.In line with this, traditions of using ethnoveterinary remedies prepared from fresh plant materials were widely observed in different cultural communities of Ethiopia, for instance, in ethnoveterinary medication of Afar people of Ada'ar District [18], Ankober District [19] and Mojana District [27].

Methods of remedy preparation and routes of application
In remedy preparation, local people and traditional healers strictly follow ways needed to get the intended livestock remedies.The current findings showed that pounding is the most common mode of ethnoveterinary remedies preparation, and closely followed by grinding.According to Gakuubi and Wanzala [73], modes of recipe preparation largely depended on the type of targeted medicinal plant, parts of plants employed, type of disease and the livestock types being treated.And also it could be related to long-term experiences of traditional healers on modes of remedy preparation and application with best preforming ethnoveterinary regimens [19].
Furthermore, local communities also took into consideration the number of medicinal plants involved while preparing herbal remedies based on ailments and livestock types.In this particular study, large portion of livestock remedies are formulated from single medicinal plants.The use of single plant species for the majority of ethnoveterinary recipes were also common in different cultural groups of Ethiopia [15,18,19,31,54] and other countries [3,60,62,[64][65][66].As Grade et al. [66] stated, the mono-preparations of veterinary remedies could be related to confidence, experiences and deep ethnoveterinary knowledge of farmers and traditional healers to select only one specific remedy.In contrast, the dominance of poly-herbal preparations were also documented in other ethno-lingual communities, such as at Bale Mountains National Park [16]; four Districts of Jimma Zone of Ethiopia [33]; and in Buuri district of Kenya [63].These authors argue that concoction of two or more plants would increase synergistic effects (effectiveness), neutralize toxicity effects and/or bitterness, palatability and ease of application of ethnoveterinary remedies.Furthermore, the use of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants is also shaped by familiarity of local communities with their environs, vegetation types, seasonality and ease of availability of herbal material in that particular area [56].
Regarding solvents used in livestock remedy preparations, cold water was the most principal solvent for remedy extraction.Similar observations were also made by ethnoveterinary studies in Ethiopia [19,28,31,33,54] and in pastoral Karamoja of Uganda [66], where cold water was preferred as best and effective solvent in extraction of active ingredient found in medicinal plant used in management of livestock diseases.However, other findings elsewhere in the world [59,61,67,68] revealed that ethnoformulation of decoctions in boiling water was the prominent methods of ethnoveterinary recipes preparation.Maphosa and Masika [23] further explained that boiling plant material in water for a long time to form a decoctions may promote extraction of water soluble polar compounds or it could detoxify harmful substances, but the method is generalized one and less carefully selected plant parts are used [67].In addition to herbal materials and water, non-plant materials such as salts, milk, butter, etc. are also used as important ingredients in ethnoveterinary system of the study area.These substances enhance ethnoveterinary remedies to be dissolved, improve its palatability and medicinal properties and as a vehicle system, during intake or topical application of remedies.Incorporating non-plant material in ethnoveterinary medicine preparation is not exceptional to the study area, while it is common practices in different ethno-lingual communities of Ethiopia [18,33] and other parts of the world [62,63,65,66].In the study area, some special mode of remedy preparation and application was also observed, for example, simple surgical method on dewlap of oxen with swollen hump, where traditional healer slice root of Kalanchoe petitiana tie with string, then insert into dewlap to drawdown pus accumulated in hump.
In addition, non-plant veterinary remedies have also been documented in the study area, which are used to treat livestock ailments, these include: mixture of charcoal, burned petrol and water (for bloating), burned petrol (for wound), ash (for wound, bone fracture or dislocation), limestone (for emaciation and ectoparasites), salt (for eye disease), urine (for bloating), edible oil (bloating), honey (for gastrointestinal disorders), dough and whey (emaciation), faeces (for wound), cattle skin (for FMD), muck (smoking for BEF), sacrifice of black female sheep or goat (for evil spirit or evil eye), spleen (for anthrax) and hot iron (for blackleg and abscess).Non-plant ethnoveterinary remedies were also recorded by similar ethnoveterinary inventories conducted elsewhere in the world [13,26,65,68,69].These uses of non-plant remedies for the management of livestock ailments could be better alternative for conservation of wild medicinal plants that are already under great threats.
As regards to sources of medicinal plants, the majority of therapeutic plants were collected from the wild.The dominance of wild medicinal plants in ethnoveterinary medicines could be related to the perceptions of indigenous people that wild plants are more potent than cultivated plants [26].In conservation point of view, the predominance of wild sources point out presence of high impact on wild ethnoveterinary medicinal plants of the area due to ethnoveterinary collections [16,19] and little practices of medicinal plant cultivation, which in long term diminish these vital plant resources.Ethnobotanical collection of medicinal plants from wild habitats for their roots put some plants under great pressure, like Withania somnifera, Phytolacca dodecandra, Cucumis ficifolius, Cyphostemma pannosum and Gomphocarpus fruticosus, as these plants are rarely found in the study area.Similarly, dependency of indigenous people on wild medicinal plant for their ethnoveterinary practices has been widely recorded by various ethnoveterinary studies in Ethiopia [15,16,18,19,49,54] and elsewhere in the world [26,62,68].As alternative to wild sources, studies advocated cultivation and conservation of medicinal plants as better strategy for livestock health and food security, overall socio-economic development of rural poor populations [54].
Oral routes administration of remedies in the form of drenching are the most frequent route of application used to treat livestock ailments.This could be related to prevalence of diseases affecting internal organs, where this route assists rapid physiological reaction with the intended disease-causing pathogens and increasing effectiveness of the medicines.Concur with present study, bulk of ethnobotanical studies have recorded oral application as prominent route in Ethiopia and other parts of the world [18,29,33,54,59,61,65].The current findings are in different to those obtained by Yirga et al. [70], who found dermal application as commonly used route of administration in ethnoveterinary medications of Seharti-Samre district, Northern Ethiopia.As the case in the present study, lack of standardized dosage for ethnoveterinary regimens were also documented in ethnoveterinary practices of different ethno-lingual communities elsewhere in the world [18,19,60,71,72], the situation that made veterinarians hesitate to use ethnoveterinary medicines.

Widely used medicinal plants and types of livestock treated
The use reports analysis showed that some ethnoveterinary medicinal plants are most widely used in ethnoveterinary services than others in the study area.As a result, Withania somnifera, Kedrostis foetidissima, Cyphostemma cyphopetalum, Gymnanthemum amygdalinum, Calpurnia aurea, Cucumis ficifolius, Senna occidentalis, Phytolacca dodecandra and Croton macrostachyus are among the wildly used medicinal plants in the study District.According to Aziz et al. [56], wide acceptance of certain medicinal plants in ethnoveterinary medicines may be due to their efficient activity, large availability in the area and long history of use in traditional medicine, the situations that make them more feasible to use than plants that are difficult to harvest.On the other hand, the most frequently mentioned medicinal plants, it does not always mean they are more effective to treat ailments than less frequently cited medicinal plants.Because some ethnoveterinary knowledge of medicinal plants are common and shared while others are more localized and specific to certain communities, family lines and even individuals [7].That means, medicinal plants with low use reports may be found in custodies of a few specialist traditional healers [7], for that matter such medicinal plants need future attentions.In this particular study, for example, ethnoveterinary knowledge related to medicinal plants used to treat rabies are very secret, held by a few individuals in the community.In addition, low use reports of medicinal plants also indicate indigenous knowledge associated with them are under risk to be lost.
The majority of ethnoveterinary plants are employed for the treatment of cattle ailments, while a few medicinal plants are used to treat goats and sheep, all livestock, equines, dogs, cats and poultry.This could be attributed to high prevalence of cattle ailments and cattle dominance in number in the study area and/or very strong cultural and economic attachments between cattle and indigenous people.Similar observations were made in other socio-cultural groups of Ethiopia, for examples, most ethnoveterinary remedies used to treat cattle in Ada'ar District of Afar region [18]; Ankober District of Amhara region [19]; and Dawuro Zone [54] of Ethiopia, which indicate better alternative to improve the welfare of cattle in the country.However, in ethnoveterinary practices of Abergelle, Sekota and Lalibela districts of Amhara region of Ethiopia, most veterinary recipes were being used to manage all domestic animals [29].Such ethnoveterinary practices might be related to presence of fair ethnoveterinary knowledge associated with all livestock types and other domestic animals for management of their respective ailments, as compared to areas with high tendency to veterinary remedies used to treat cattle diseases.

Ethnoveterinary ailment category and fidelity level of medicinal plants
The informants' consensus factor (ICF) for each ailment category is found between the ranges of (0.69-0.94).The results indicated that there is a well-defined selection criterion in the study community and informants have great agreement on indigenous and local knowledge of ethnoveterinary plants and practices [73].It also determines the cultural consistency of the selection of a set of medicinal plants used in the treatment of a certain illness category [39].The highest ICF values indicate high incidence of the disease category in the area.As well as, medicinal plants used to treat ailment categories are probably with high potency and important to select potential candidate medicinal plants for phytochemical and pharmacological research.
Furthermore, gastrointestinal diseases are reported to be treated by large number of medicinal plants as well as with high number of citations.Dermatological diseases are also treated by good number of therapeutic plants.This might be due to high prevalence of these disease categories in the study area.It also indicated that local people share the knowledge of the most important medicinal plants to treat the most frequently encountered livestock ailments in the area.Similar ethnoveterinary survey carried out in Ankober District of Ethiopia also recorded gastrointestinal, ecto-and endo-parasitic and dermatological as major and prevalent ailment categories of the area [19].Berhanu et al. [57], similarly, reported that gastrointestinal, dermatological and febrile disorders are ailment categories with high frequency in Ambo District of Ethiopia.In addition, as botanical surveys in different part of the world indicate gastrointestinal disorders are the most frequently reported and prevalent ailment category throughout the world [56,59,64,65,73].
Medicinal plants with high fidelity-level value (> 50%) in each ailment category showed that these plants are abundantly found in the area and frequently used by local communities in the treatment of livestock ailments.As explained in Friedman et al. [74], if FL > 50%, then there is high degree of consensus around the use of this species for treatment of that particular ailment category, which makes plant appropriate candidate to treat this type of disease.It also shows relatively high healing potential of the species for treating ailments under the respective ailment categories and good candidate for further pharmacological studies [75].However, some medicinal plants including Cyphostemma cyphopetalum, Withania somnifera, Gymnanthemum amygdalina and Cucumis ficifolius had low FL values in their respective disease categories.The low FL values show the local inhabitants disagree on use of medicinal plants to treat particular ailment categories, it could be due their multipurpose in ethnoveterinary medicine formulation.

Relative importance of ethnoveterinary plants
In Dugda District, 27 (42.19%)medicinal plants were reported to be multipurpose species with diversity of remedies ranges (2-8 remedies).In this regard, the most multipurpose medicinal plant species in the study area were Croton macrostachyus, Kedrostis foetidissima, Withania somnifera, Senna occidentalis and Gymnanthemum amygdalinum.For instance, C. macrostachyus was used to treat eight specific ailments and five disease categories including gastrointestinal, dermatological, musculoskeletal, neurological and general illness.Similar observation was made by Dinbiso et al. [54] and Lulekal et al. [19] in Dawuro Zone and Ankober District of Ethiopia, where C. macrostachyus is used for treatment of multiple veterinary ailments, 10 and 8 ailments, respectively.Multipurpose of W. somnifera and G. amygdalinum are also documented in ethnoveterinary practices of four District of Jimma zone of Ethiopia [33].Similarly, S. occidentalis is also a multipurpose species in other part of Africa [66,76].According to Giday and Teklehaymanot [18], medicinal plants with high relative importance (RI) indicate their relative abundance in that particular area.Furthermore, these plants are the most widely utilized ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in Ethiopian ethnoveterinary medicines [15,19,28,29,32].Multipurpose of these medicinal plants could be attributed to their phytochemical constituents with wide spectrum bioactivity against wide range of ailments.Of the nine ailment categories, gastrointestinal ailments were reported to be treated by high number of medicinal plants, and closely followed by dermatological and general illness.In support of these results, Bennett and Prance [52] explained that gastrointestinal, skin and respiratory remedies are the most frequently reported types of medicines throughout the world.

Distribution of ethnoveterinary medicinal plant knowledge
In the present study, the comparison of ethnoveterinary medicinal plant knowledge showed significant difference, where key informants cited more medicinal plants than general informants.This could be attributed to the secret practice and transfer of ethnoveterinary knowledge along the family line, to safeguard their benefits from the knowledge and fear of loses of healing power of plant when disclosed.And it could be also related to long-term experience of key informants in using medicinal plants to treat livestock ailments.These findings in line with previous ethnoveterinary researches in Ethiopia [27,28] that showed significant difference between key and general informants in ethnoveterinary plant knowledge.There was no significant difference observed in medicinal plant mentioned by male and female informants.A similar observations were made in another ethnoveterinary inventories in Ethiopia [27,54] and differ from that of Asfaw et al. [28].The comparison of medicinal plants cited by the two age groups (20-39 years and 40-87 years) showed significance difference.This indicates matured groups are more knowledgeable than young groups in using medicinal plants for veterinary uses, which was also reported from the early work [19], but dissimilar with that of [54].It might be related to high experience of elders, close connection to natural ecosystem and livestock, faith on medicinal plant healing power and also knowledge gaps between generations.Similarly, the number of medicinal plants cited by illiterate and literate informants showed significant difference.This disparity could be attributed to the reliance of illiterate communities on medicinal plants to manage livestock ailments, while educated people prefer other options mostly modern drugs.It might be also related to poor connection of educated people with the traditional societies and natural ecosystems.Similar finding has been reported in ethnobotanical researches elsewhere in Ethiopia [19,27].In conclusion, ethnoveterinary medicinal plants knowledge is being threatened by globalization, expansion of modern education and ways of the knowledge transfer.

Importance of the current study in animal health and food security
Animal health is the important concern of ethnoveterinary study, because livestock are one of the pillar on which the livelihood of the communities rests.In the study area, the most prevalent ailments are anthrax, inappetence, diarrhoea, rabies, bloating, blackleg and mange.The aforementioned ailments are also the commonly encountered livestock ailments elsewhere in Ethiopia, which can cause substantial losses in livestock and lower productivity [14,21].The people in the study District and majority of livestock raisers elsewhere in Ethiopia have limited access to modern animal health services to deal with the encountered livestock ailments [77].This is because local communities are geographically far from the sites of veterinary stations and those that are closer to the sites may not afford the fees for services.In such areas, farmers and pastoralists partly or solely depend on ethnoveterinary medicinal plants to sustain animal health.As described by Silva et al. [78], local people intentional or unintentional use therapeutic plants as ethnoveterinary medicine for food-producing animals that could improve the well-being and quality of derived-food products.This makes ethnoveterinary medicines a good alternative to modern drugs that used to manage livestock health in general and food-producing animals, in particular [78].Particularly, its significance is paramount in arid and semi-arid areas, as livestock provide major food security in times of crop failure [10].Because livestock tend to be more resilient than crops when disasters such as drought and floods strike [79].Thus, ethnoveterinary medicinal plants could play a vital role in such areas to improve livestock health, which in turn used to ensure household food security and income generation options, and contribute to national livestock economy.Moreover, medicinal plants has the potential to improve the economic status of local communities and in alleviating poverty through marketing and long-term use [54].
When using ethnoveterinary medicine, we have to be curious about its dosage, since dosage is a determining factor, in small quantities as medicinal and large amounts may leads to toxicity or lethal to animals.In study area, some reported ethnoveterinary medicinal plants are with toxic potential (e.g.Croton macrostachyus, Melia azedarach, Xanthium spinosum, Calotropis procera, Datura stramonium and Phytolacca dodecandra).The ethnoveterinary practices of these medicinal plants could be poison due to substance accumulation (residues) or overdose [78].The ethnoveterinary practices of toxic plants can be harmful to livestock, risky to human health (a concern on food safety) and may lead to harmful economic consequences [78].Therefore, as stated by Silva et al. [78], shortcomings of ethnoveterinary practices are toxicity/inefficacy and lack of standardization that should be validated through pharmacological properties studies with toxicity investigations.
Furthermore, some prevalent livestock ailments in the study area are zoonotic diseases (anthrax and rabies), which are treated by medicinal plants.Anthrax and rabies are among the five prioritized zoonotic diseases that Ethiopia has committed to control, using a One Health approach [10].Thus, current findings also offer crucial insight for One Health approach in controlling zoonotic diseases in Ethiopia and beyond and also illustrate the importance of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in both livestock and human health problems.

Comparison with previous studies in Ethiopia
Comparison of current study with the ethnoveterinary studies in Ethiopia showed that 56 medicinal plants are documented in various similar studies in the country to treat different livestock ailments.The most frequently documented medicinal plants include Achyranthes aspera, Calpurnia aurea, Croton macrostachyus, Cucumis ficifolius, Datura stramonium, Phytolacca dodecandra, Solanum incanum, Verbascum sinaiticum and Gymnanthemum amygdalinum (Table 8).Tihahu et al. [21] also reported the frequent utilization of these ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in the country.According to Lulekal et al. [19], similarity in use of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in different communities could be attributed to cross-cultural exchange of indigenous knowledge among different ethnic groups, within similar ethnic group and also availability of the species in use in those areas.This could be also related to similarity in climatic and weather conditions, geographical location and communities' faith on medicinal plants healing power [21].In addition, their frequent utilization might be coincide with the presence of bioactive ingredients against livestock ailments [21], as evidenced in various pharmacological studies and shown promising antimicrobial activities [80].
Some reported medicinal plants are also widely used as ethnoveterinary medications in different countries of the world too [26, 59-61, 64, 65, 67, 68, 76, 81-85].Just to mention a few Allium sativum, Melia azedarach, Calotropis procera, Cissus quadrangularis, Foeniculum vulgare, Nicotiana tabacum, Opuntia ficus-indica and Withania somnifera.This similarity could be due to mixing of cultural knowledge through globalization, substitution of native species for exotic, naturalization of exotic species, cosmopolitan nature of species in use and its associated knowledge [60].The substitution of native species by exotic ones have tremendous effects on the survival of native species and the knowledge associated with them, which could be lost forever, thus it needs research into documentation of information about neglected native plants and their uses [60].Perhaps, documentation of traditional knowledge of native or exotic ethnoveterinary medicinal plant species is crucial as they help in providing herbal materials for the discovery of new low-cost drugs that are environmentally friendly and conservation of biodiversity [19].
In this study, eight ethnoveterinary medicinal plants were reported for the first time in treatment of livestock ailments.These medicinal plants include Capparis fascicularis for treatment of eye, Desmidorchis retrospiciens for constipation, Dombeya torrida for mange, diarrhoea and colic.Erianthemum dregei and Loranthella schimperi for muscle stiffness/ataxia and inappetence, Oreosyce africana for anthrax and equine diseases.Pappea capensis for treatment of new born rejection (poor mothering) in cattle and Persicaria decipiens is used to treat emaciation and remove retained placenta.Thus, these plants need to be studied for their phytochemical constituents and biological activities, which could be important components in future veterinary pharmaceuticals.
Some new ethnoveterinary uses of medicinal plants are also recorded in the study area.For instance, traditional remedy prepared by concoction of four medicinal plants including Phytolacca dodecandra (leaves), Calpurnia aurea (seed), Cyphostemma cyphopetalum (root) and Verbascum sinaiticum, then mixed with milk or blood and given to dogs, one drop to their left nostril and ear, which is used for prophylaxis against rabies.In some sites, the remedy also formulated from grounded seeds of C. aurea mixed with milk or blood, then given to dogs following the same procedure.According to local people and traditional healers, the remedy is used as traditional vaccine against rabies.The remedy is given to the healthy dog to prevent rabies, which serve at least for one year.As rabies is one of deadly disease in Ethiopia and elsewhere in the world, such medicinal indications are important for its prevention and need further investigations.

Conservation status, threats to ethnoveterinary plants and indigenous knowledge
The conservation status of reported ethnoveterinary medicinal plants were checked on the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List.According to the IUCN Red List, 20 (31.25%) reported ethnoveterinary medicinal plants are documented in different conservation status, which includes 18 (28.125%)species that are least concern (LC), 2 species that are vulnerable (VU) and data deficient (DD).The remaining 44 medicinal plants are not documented/classified on the IUCN Red List, this might indicates their conservation status not assessed or they have least threats to conservation.

Conclusions
The study revealed that the people of Dugda District are endowed with rich ethnoveterinary knowledge, practices and medicinal plants.As a result, a total of 64 medicinal plants were identified and documented along with their detailed veterinary uses and to be used to treat a wide ranges of livestock ailments.Anthrax, inappetence and diarrhoea were the most prevalent and treat by large number of medicinal plants.The study also showed that ethnoveterinary knowledge of medicinal plants have a remarkable value to deal with these livestock health problems, particularly in areas with limited access to modern pharmaceuticals and rural poor populations.Family Fabaceae was the most important in ethnoveterinary uses (7 spp.), followed by Apocynaceae, Cucurbitaceae and Solanaceae (5

Table 3
Ethnoveterinary medicinal plants with the highest use reports

Table 4
Informant consensus factor of ethnoveterinary ailment category Nt: Number of plants (s) mentioned for the treatment of these particular disease groups, Nur: Number of times a particular category of diseases is cited, ICF: informant consensus factorAilment categoryNt %

Table 5
Fidelity-level value of top three medicinal plants commonly reported against ethnoveterinary ailment category Ip: number of informants who independently cited ailment category; Iu: total number of informants who reported the plants for any given ailment category; FL: fidelity level

Table 6
Relative importance of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in Dugda District NSA = number of specific ailments; NAC = number of ailment categories; NP = NSA treated by a given species divided by the total NSA treated by the most multipurpose species.NCS = NAC treated by a given species divided by the total NAC treated by the most multipurpose species, RI = Relative importance value

Table 7
Statistical test of significance among different informant groups based on number of reported medicinal plants by informants in Dugda District *Significant difference (p < 0.05); ** t(0.05) (two tailed), df = 376, N = Number of respondents, NMP = Number of medicinal plants, SD = Standard Deviation, yrs = years

Table 8
Comparison of reported ethnoveterinary medicinal plants with previous studies in Ethiopia

Table 8 (continued) Medicinal plants and CS Ailments treated in Dugda District Ailments recorded in previous study in different regions of Ethiopia treated by recorded medicinal plants AmR AfR OR SR SNNPR TR
: Conservation status; LC: Least concern, VU: Vulnerable; DD: Data Deficient; lAmR: Amhara Region; AfR: Afar Region; OR: Oromia Region; SR: Somali Region; SNNPR: Southern Nation, Nationalities and Peoples Region; TR: Tigray Region, BER: Bovine ephemeral fever, FMD: Foot and mouth disease, CCPP: contagious caprine pleuropneumonia; CBPP: contagious bovine pleuropneumonia; PPR: Peste des petits ruminants; LSD: Lumpy skin disease; Tryps: trypanosomiasis; AHS: African horse sickness into mono-cropping system that led to decline in the multipurpose and medicinal plants in the District.Medicinal plants are also highly affected by overgrazing as large livestock population are freely grazing in Acacia woodland,

Table 9
List of ethnoveterinary medicinal plants in single plant remedy preparations/formulations